The Jelly Bean Theory of Choices

Today, I am in a storytelling mood - despite the fact that I have a Cell Biology exam tomorrow. It’s surprising how the brain works, isn't it? Always finding new ways to avoid work exactly when you need it the most. But after punishing my mind long enough with the intricacies of cell cycle regulation and signalling pathways, I decided to give it a break - to tell the story of how I ended up here, at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Mumbai, pursuing my first year as a PhD scholar.

I decided very early in my college life that I wanted to do research and stay in academia. And once I had that clarity, I went all in. I worked in labs, applied for internships, even stayed at college whilst all my family members were at a function. It wasn’t easy, but it felt purposeful. By the end of my Master’s coursework, I was confident that my profile would mean something to potential supervisors. I imagined that soon I’d be in a lab that truly fit my curiosity.

Then came the reality check. I had applied to a dozen institutes in Europe and from each one of them, came the nicely worded, polite rejection email. Each one stung a little more than the last. It didn’t help that I was already on antidepressants at the time. "So now I’m both mentally sick and incompetent,” I remember thinking. Those emails always include the line - ‘Please note that this says nothing about your capabilities’ - but it was hard to keep it impersonal.

On the side, I had also applied to Indian institutes, but the application and interview processes were so unimaginative and in general, lacked the ‘we welcome open ideas and discussions’ environment such that I had given up on them too. I decided to take a year’s break and work someplace as a Project Assistant or so. I conveyed my decision to my parents - who were really trying hard to be supportive of my career and hence, accepted it with a tinge of anguish.

That conversation happened over a weekend. By the following week, I had my interviews scheduled at TIFR. 

Now, I am not a morning person - at all. So at 8 in the morning, I was still deliberating whether it was worth even getting up for my interview at 8:30. I finally gave in, thinking ‘Why not?’. All through my life, I have asked myself a lot of ‘Why not?’s, but this would be among the most significant ones. 

After the first round, I told my family, “This is how a PhD interview should be.”
After the second, I said, “If I go further, I might actually consider joining.”
And after the one-on-one sessions with the PIs, I knew: this was a place where I could grow - not just as a researcher, but as a person.

Now, two months into this journey, I sometimes look back on those darker days and feel a strange tenderness for them. They were hard, yes, but they were also formative.

Without a doubt, for most of us, the transition from University at an Undergrad or Postgrad level to the Transitions - from university to research, from structure to self-direction - are among the hardest phases we experience in early adulthood. I’m sure there are greater challenges ahead, but at this stage, this feels like the most difficult one yet.

Why, though? Why is this so hard?

I’ve thought a lot about that, and I think it all comes down to choice.

I once watched an episode of Mind Field called Freedom of Choice. The host, Michael Stevens, performed an experiment with jelly beans. One group could choose from just two flavours; the other had over twenty options. Unsurprisingly, people with fewer choices were happier with their selection, while those with many options felt more regret - the eternal “what if I’d chosen the other one?” dilemma.

In high school, my choices were simple - biology, computer science, or commerce. The clarity was comforting; the boundaries, well-defined. But as I grew older, the choices multiplied. Industry or higher studies? If higher studies, where? And in which field? Each decision came with a parallel list of consequences: Will I be able to sustain myself? Will I make my family proud? Will I even be happy?

As young adults stepping into the real world, we’re forced to make decisions before we’ve even fully met ourselves. And with every new option comes the gnawing feeling that there might always be something better out there - another path, another flavour. Maybe there is. Maybe there isn’t. Maybe it’s all a matter of perception.

We’re often told that our choices are permanent, irreversible, and that we must live with their consequences. Every quote on the internet seems to reinforce that. But I don’t believe it - or maybe I refuse to. The idealist in me insists that we’re always free to choose again, to redirect both our thoughts and actions toward a new purpose.

Dumbledore, as always, was right: It is our choices that show what we truly are, far more than our abilities.

My life so far has been one long experiment in trial and error — in career, friendships, relationships, and purpose. The goal is to learn from each outcome and do better in the next trial. I am happier, and more importantly. with a resolve, when I believe this.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Limits of Resolution

Ghosts of Memories Past

Death by Insecurity